NFL Fans Shocked as 49ers Move to Cut Rising Star Running Back

In a decision that’s ignited outrage across social media, the San Francisco 49ers are reportedly preparing to cut rookie running back Isaac Guerendo, despite his rising popularity and impressive preseason performance. What’s fueling the backlash? A reason many fans are calling “ridiculous,” “shortsighted,” and “unbelievable.”

Who Is Isaac Guerendo?

Isaac Guerendo, an undrafted rookie from Louisville, had quickly become a fan favorite during offseason workouts and mini camps. Known for his:

• Elite speed and breakaway ability

• Solid vision and footwork

• And a strong showing in early practices and scrimmages

Guerendo was considered a potential secret weapon for the 49ers backfield, especially in a run-heavy offense led by head coach Kyle Shanahan.

The “Ridiculous” Reason Behind the Cut

According to team insiders, the 49ers’ coaching staff is reportedly concerned that Guerendo’s playing style “doesn’t fully align” with the current scheme — a reason that many fans and analysts say makes no sense at all.

In fact, some insiders suggest the team is prioritizing “veteran loyalty” over pure talent, as the depth chart favors older backs despite Guerendo’s upside.

Fan Reaction: Outrage Erupts on Social Media

Social media exploded within minutes of the report:

🔥 “You’re cutting Isaac Guerendo for scheme fit? That’s a joke!”
🔥 “One of the only young guys showing real promise and THIS is the decision?”
🔥 “The 49ers are making a mistake they’ll regret when he signs elsewhere and thrives.”

The hashtag #KeepGuerendo is already trending among the 49ers faithful.

What This Means for the 49ers

Cutting Guerendo could backfire in several ways:

• Losing a breakout talent that could thrive elsewhere

• Damaging fan trust, especially among those rooting for underdogs

• Reinforcing concerns that the 49ers resist change in favor of sticking with “safe” options

With a Super Bowl window still open, fans question whether this move will help—or hurt—the team long-term.

Final Thoughts: Short-Term Strategy or Long-Term Mistake?

While final rosters haven’t been confirmed yet, the buzz around Isaac Guerendo’s rumored release has already sparked one of the offseason’s biggest controversies.

If the 49ers go through with this move, they may soon watch a hidden gem flourish in another uniform — all because of a “ridiculous” reason.